
One is a hard-nosed, backroom brawler, the type of quarterback who will lower his shoulder in the hole rather than darting to the sideline for cover. The type of quarterback that gets his helmet ripped and it does nothing but ignite him. The type of quarterback that does pretty much nothing but win.
The other is a gunslinging Islander whose sharp focus, swagger-laden performances and unflappable psyche contrasts his quiet personality. The type of quarterback who makes the impossible seem simple, the type of quarterback who can make throws very few other signal callers in the country can make. The type of quarterback that is starving for his first rivalry win as a starter.
The brawler is Justin Lamson, a sixth-year senior captain who quickly made Bobcat Nation forget its worry about who would ever replace Tommy Mellott. Lamson has only played in the rivalry against Montana for one year. But he already has as many wins over the Griz (2) as Mellott had in 3.5 years as the starter.
Lamson’s posted two of the most memorable performances by a Bobcat quarterback against the Grizzlies. Lamson is 2-0 against Montana after playing a big part in helping the ‘Cats post a signature 31-28 win in Missoula last fall. Less than a month later, Lamson’s throw to a streaking Taco Dowler on a 3rd down & 20 in the 4th quarter of a tight national semifinal rivalry game helped swing the momentum fully in the host Bobcats’ favor. That swing helped Montana State surmount a 23-20 deficit to race to a 48-23 victory to book a second consecutive trip to the FCS title game.

“He’s a threat both throwing and running. He’s a big, strong guy. He made some plays against us in the past, but he’s kind of a two-headed monster. He does things, and he does them well. It’s kind of like every week in this league. There’s quality quarterbacks that we have to defend, and he’s definitely at the top of the list,” Montana head coach Bobby Kennedy said during his weekly press conference on Monday.
Cool Hand KAY is Keali’i Ah Yat, Montana’s wheeling, dealing, steady trigger man who’s taken his game yet another level up in his fourth year in a Griz jersey. As a freshman in 2023, he showed bright flashes in spot duty. In 2024, he endured a brutal quarterback carousel with Logan Fife and played sparingly in Montana’s 34-11 loss to MSU in Bozeman. Two weeks later however, Ah Yat took over as UM’s starting quarterback against South Dakota State in the playoffs and has never looked back.
Over the last two seasons, Ah Yat has completed nearly 70 percent of his passes for 7,265 yards, 63 touchdowns and just 14 interceptions. Other than a tipped ball that ended up in a Caden Dowler pick-6 in Brawl 1.0 last season, Ah Yat was sharp and locked in. After losing Brooks Davis and Evan Shafer before the second quarter was three minutes in, Ah Yat still managed to keep the Griz afloat before the dam broke. The 3rd & 20 along with Bryce Grebe’s pick-6 were both detrimental as UM’s season ended with just two losses – both to the Bobcats, both in the span of a month.

“He’s very talented. He’s got a wealth of experience, and he’s just gotten better and better each time we’ve faced him,” Montana State head coach Brent Vigen said Monday. “While the people he’s throwing to have continued to change, he’s been able to work through that, and their passing game has probably evolved as his experience is growing. He’s been particularly good at the deep ball, more and more as his career has gone along, so we have to limit those opportunities.”
Ah Yat got off to a “slow” start, at least considering his preseason expectation level, the fact that he returned as the lone first-team All-Big Sky quarterback in the conference and the fact that he returned much of his offense, including coordinator Brent Pease, All-American running back Eli Gillman and budding star wide receiver Brooks Davis.
Through Montana’s first four games, Ah Yat threw for 1,033 yards, seven touchdowns and one interception. He went 15-of-28 for 265 yards, two scores and a pick in a 28-21 escape against Southern Utah in Kennedy’s debut. He was 27-of-40 for 240 yards and two touchdowns in a 52-17 drubbing at Oregon State.
Montana has had a few turning points during its season. One came when the Griz bulldozed UC Davis 62-22. Ah Yat was good that day (21-of-31 for 241 yards with two touchdown passes and two touchdown runs) but Gillman stole the show, breaking a 25-year-old single-game rushing record by plowing his way to 275 yards and scoring four touchdowns.
The following week, Ah Yat looked like Marcus Mariota light, throwing for 346 yards on 23-of-30 passing and five touchdowns against Northern Colorado. The Griz left points on the field but still won going away, 36-14 on homecoming.
Ah Yat’s strong performances against Northern Arizona (29-of-39, 347 yards, three touchdowns) and Idaho (25-of-31, 338 yards, five touchdowns) were completely overshadowed by a defense that couldn’t get off the field.
That two-game losing streak, UM’s first since 2022, pushed Bobby Kennedy’s first season to the brink. But a bye week, some defensive adjustments and Ah Yat’s elevated play helped UM take a three-game winning streak into a rivalry game that UM is trying to snap a three-game losing streak in.
“This is where great players are made, right here, for the championship,” Ah Yat said Monday. “We all know what’s at stake, so I just can’t wait. I try my best to just block out the noise, the crowd. Playing in there last year was loud, so we’ve got to be ready for that. I’m just excited. I can’t wait to go there and play.”
Lamson enters Saturday’s showdown with an undefeated record against Big Sky opponents and an undefeated record at home. Montana State’s lone loss this season, a 35-34 stunner at Idaho, came with Lamson on the shelf after he had a minor knee procedure that cost him MSU’s 28-14 win over Northern Arizona and that Idaho loss.
This season, he’s thrown for 1,958 yards and 14 touchdowns against just one interception while completing 71.7 percent of his passes. He’s rushed for 278 yards and seven touchdowns. His rushing numbers are down from 2025, a season that saw him run for 734 yards and 16 touchdowns while also throwing for 3,172 yards and 26 scores.

Since his return from injury, Lamson has been particularly impressive. In a 28-26 triple overtime win over Idaho State, Lamson seemed ignited when he got his helmet ripped off by ISU defensive end Bronson Childs. That play opened a gash over his eye but also seemed to light a fire inside him. He finished the day 22-of-37 for 209 yards, plus 46 rushing yards. His 20-yard touchdown throw to Rocky Lencioni on a 4th down and 10 to go with about two and a half minutes to play in Pocatello is one of the plays of the season thus far.
Last week, Lamson was uber-efficient, completing 24-of-28 passes for 246 yards and running for two touchdowns in a 31-21 win over Northern Colorado.
“To win big games, you have to play well at that position. It’s just a fact,” Vigen said. “Rarely can you mask that spot in big games, and he’s done it. He’s done it against this opponent a couple times, and he’s done it in high-pressure situations, period. He’s all the things you want at that position this time of year: a guy that’s seasoned, a guy that’s confident, a guy that’s competitive as heck. And I think he has a sound understanding of what this rivalry means to the people in this state, to his teammates that are from Montana.”
The numbers frame Saturday’s quarterback duel about as starkly as possible.
Ah Yat is 25-7 as Montana’s starter, a winning percentage that stacks up with nearly any quarterback in the country. But he is just 7-5 on the road. And his only two road wins against teams with winning records came at Sacramento State last season and at UC Davis earlier this fall.

Now he heads into one of the most hostile environments in the FCS, one Kennedy saw firsthand last December as an assistant.
“I’ve seen both sides of it,” Kennedy said on 102.9 ESPN on Wednesday. “Obviously their crowd is really loud and very excitable, and so it’s not like it’s my first time going into this game, so that’s a good thing.”
Lamson, meanwhile, has been nearly flawless since arriving from Stanford. He is 23-2 as Montana State’s starter, including 13-1 at Bobcat Stadium, and he has never lost a Big Sky game in Bozeman.
He is also trying to do something no quarterback in Big Sky Conference history has done. Montana State is chasing a second straight national championship. No football program in the league has ever won back-to-back national titles. Montana won FCS crowns in 1995 and 2001. Eastern Washington won in 2010. Montana State won in 1984 and again last January, when Lamson was named the title game’s MVP.
Vigen, who became Montana State’s all-time winningest coach with his 71st victory last week, has kept his team’s eyes on that bigger picture all season.
“We’ve been able to continue to raise the bar,” Vigen said Monday. “Not that we’ve won them all by any means, but we won a lot of them, and that’s reflected, I guess, in hitting that milestone. But we have a lot left to accomplish this particular year, and that’s center of my mind right now.”
The stakes Saturday stretch well beyond bragging rights.
For Montana, a win would almost certainly lock up a Top 8 seed and the home-field advantage that comes with it through at least the second round. A loss would likely leave the Griz hosting a first-round playoff game as a double-digit seed, with a long road ahead.
“At the end of the season, two good teams. What’s better than a championship on the line, playoffs, go in with a little momentum?” Kennedy said. “There’s a lot at stake, and by no means the team that gets knocked off, I don’t think that they’re knocked out of other bigger things that could happen. But it’s important, and it’s important for our program and theirs as well.”
For Montana State, a win would clinch the No. 1 overall seed, a third straight outright Big Sky Conference championship and the fourth league title in Vigen’s six seasons in Bozeman. The Bobcats already clinched at least a share of the crown last week. That’s not the goal.
“I don’t think it says ‘share the Big Sky title’ on anything that we’re after,” Vigen said. “I don’t mean that as a level of any disrespect. We want to be able to win it outright. Winning the Big Sky Conference is something we aim to do. But again, ultimately, winning it outright is what we’re after.”
One quarterback has made a habit of winning the biggest games. The other has been stellar, but is still searching for his signature rivalry game victory. On Saturday at Bobcat Stadium, one of them will add the defining chapter to his quarterback story.





